ELECTION RESULTS: Madison overwhelmingly rejects city manager proposal
Madison City Hall
Madison, Madison County Record, May 9 Special Election, News, RSS Twitter, Z - BREAKING NEWS, Z - News Main
 By  FROM STAFF REPORTS Published 
9:02 pm Tuesday, May 9, 2023

ELECTION RESULTS: Madison overwhelmingly rejects city manager proposal

By Maria Rakoczy

MADISON – On Tuesday, May 9, Madison citizens resoundingly voted to reject the city manager proposal.

The unofficial numbers reported Tuesday night stand with ‘yes’ votes numbering 1,865 and ‘no’ votes totaling at 5,553. Nearly 75% of the 7418 voters casting their ballot in the special election wanted to stay with the current mayor-council form of government.

In the wake of the election results, Mayor Paul Finley stated, “The city of Madison was happy to see engaged citizens for this election. Our community voiced its opinion to continue operating under a Mayor-Council form of government. We have a proven track record of success with this form of government, and we have managed growth and numerous projects for long-term progress. Your elected officials will continue to work hard for quality of life in Madison. Whichever way you cast your vote, as Council and Mayor, we are encouraged in our community’s involvement with municipal government.”

For years, city leaders have been pushing for Madison to adopt a city manager form of government, saying the move will bring better stability to the operations of the city. Mayor Paul Finley kicked off the process by appointing a committee in August 2021 tasked with looking into the proposed change and developing a recommendation for the city council. In early 2022, the “Madison Governance Transition Committee” unanimously recommended that the city should shift to a council-manager form of government.

A similar push was initiated in 2015, but never made it to a public vote.

To bring the issue before the people in an election this time, as required by law, a petition dispersed by a local citizens group, Madison Forward, was approved by Limestone County and Madison County probate judges in February.

If the change had been approved by a majority of voters, it would have required redistricting Madison from the current seven districts to six, with the mayor serving as an elected-at-large city council president. The mayor would have become the “face of the city”, representing Madison in public events and in meetings with neighboring cities, and a city council-appointed city manager would run the daily operations of the city.

The proposal generated lively debate in the weeks and months leading up to the election.

Now, the city council will canvas the ballots from Tuesday’s vote at a special council meeting next Tuesday, May 16 at 12 pm. The official count of votes will come out after that meeting and notice will be given to state offices and the probate court of those results.

Below are the election unofficial results:

Also on The Madison Record
MADISON BOWL 2026: Battle of rivals and friends
b-Sports, Events, Madison County Record, ...
Battle of rivals and friends
Bob Labbe 
September 2, 2026
MADISON- Two words are the origin for the enormous excitement across Madison this week: “Madison Bowl.” The annual battle lines between the two high s...
DOWNTOWN VISION: Residents, businesses say what they would like to see downtown
A: Main, Madison County Record, News, ...
Staff Reports 
September 2, 2026
MADISON - Madison holds a lot of potential to become a bustling shopping, dining, entertainment, and business district. The city of Madison along with...
Mayor Ranae Bartlett applauds Madison youth in varying, outstanding accomplishments
Madison County Record, News, The Madison Recor, ...
MADISON WEEKLY
Gregg Parker 
September 2, 2026
MADISON – Madison teenagers actively pursue progress in their endeavors, while their parents and mentors define avenues for them to succeed. These sce...
Rod and Brenda Matthews earn Main Street Hero Award for Bellehouse Venue
Lifestyles, Madison County Record, News, ...
Gregg Parker 
September 2, 2026
MADISON – Bellehouse Venue at 4097 Sullivan St. in downtown Madison received the “Main Street Hero Award” at Main Street Alabama’s Summit of Excellenc...
What’s the best groove? Battle of the Bands to decide at Home Place Park on Sept. 12
Events, Madison County Record, News, ...
Gregg Parker 
September 2, 2026
MADISON – After its premiere in 2025, “Battle of the Bands” is returning to decide who will rule the stage at Home Place Park, 100 Shorter St. Madison...
MCS’ 10-week class, ‘Raising the Strong-Willed Child,’ to begin Sept 14
Madison County Record, News, Schools, ...
Gregg Parker 
September 2, 2026
MADISON – “Jake takes after his grandfather.” “Oh, it’s just a phase.” “Ashley is as stubborn as his mother.” Parents may say or hear these statements...
HISTORY: Miss Hessie continued – The unique house she built at 313 Church Street
Lifestyles, Madison County Record, News, ...
EXPLORING LOCAL HISTORY WITH MARIA
Maria Rakoczy 
September 2, 2026
MADISON - Last week’s article looked at the beloved Madison schoolteacher Nancy Hesseltine Gillespie Farley ‘Miss Hessie’s’ life. This week continues ...
Clift Farm announces first annual Clift Farm Classic 5K & Fun Run, Sept. 12
Events, Madison County Record, News, ...
STAFF REPORTS news@themadisonrecord.com 
September 2, 2026
MADISON – Clift Farm is inviting runners, walkers and families from across Madison and surrounding communities to lace up for the inaugural Clift Farm...

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *