Letter to the Editor: Madison does not need a city manager, vote no
May 9 Special Election
 By  John Few Published 
8:17 am Wednesday, April 26, 2023

Letter to the Editor: Madison does not need a city manager, vote no

Dear Editor,
I moved to Madison 10 years ago after living out of state for nearly 14 years. For me, Madison was a convenient spot nestled halfway between Huntsville and Decatur, where I work. I loved the slightly rural feel of the community with small hobby farms scattered around the city and it reminded me of Hoover, AL where I grew up.

I quickly fell in love with the Tennessee valley and was glad to live north of the chaotic traffic that plagues the Birmingham metro area. Since moving here, Madison has experienced a good deal of growth, which is similar to what Hoover experienced over the past 30 years.

Madison is projected to grow further, and some are suggesting we need a city manager to help manage this growth. My question is why? Why do we need to completely transform our local government because our city is growing? Hoover, AL more than doubled in size from a population of 41,000 in 1990 to over 92,000 in 2020, all without a city manager.

Proponents of city manager also suggest this change is needed to help our schools. I ask again, why? Madison already has a plan for building additional schools based on expected future population growth. In fact, since I’ve lived here, a new high school and a new elementary school have been built, and a new middle school will open next year. Last month, the Madison City School board announced another new elementary school will be built in Limestone County next year. Madison is already building new schools without a city manager.

How much will the city manager cost taxpayers? We don’t know, the city council can’t tell us anything until after voters approve the change. We should look at a city like Dothan, AL with a similar population (71,000) to Madison to get an idea.

Dothan is more comparable to Madison in terms of population than two cities used as examples in the Madison government transition public meetings, Mountain Brook (22,000) and Vestavia (39,000). So why wasn’t Dothan used as an example or investigated by Madison’s governance transition committee?

Most likely because it is fraught with controversy. In April 2019, Dothan hired its current city manager at a base salary of $190,000 plus a $700 per month auto allowance. A similar salary has been discussed as consideration for a city manager in Madison. So, what’s the catch? Within in a year of his hiring, Dothan’s city manager convinced the board of commissioners (city council) to hire an assistant city manager at a salary of $154,000 plus a $500 car allowance. The idea of an assistant city manager and the additional salary wasn’t mentioned at all by the transition committee or those who support this change in Madison. Other costs like moving expenses, health insurance, and other benefits also have to be considered.

Madison doesn’t need a city manager. I suggest voters mark your calendar now for May 9 and vote no.

Kathy Patrick
Don’t Mess With Madison,
assistant treasurer
Resident of Madison

Also on The Madison Record
A: Main, Madison County Record, News, ...
Staff Reports 
November 18, 2026
MADISON - Madison has been named the second best small city in America by Livability. com. In its inaugural list of the 50 Best Small Cities, the data...
A brother’s legacy builds joy for children battling cancer
A: Main, Lifestyles, Madison County Record, ...
Ten years after Josh Quist’s passing, his sister revives a LEGO toy drive to bring comfort and creativity to local children fighting cancer
Staff Reports 
November 18, 2026
HUNTSVILLE — For Josh Quist, a LEGO set offered something childhood cancer couldn’t take away: the freedom to imagine, create and simply be a kid. Ten...
Bartlett salutes Armed Forces whose service ‘spans decades and continents’
Madison County Record, News, The Madison Recor, ...
MADISON WEEKLY
Gregg Parker 
November 18, 2026
MADISON – In appreciation for all military personnel, Mayor Ranae Bartlett and Councilmembers Billie Goodson, Alice Lessmann and Erica White represent...
14 arrested in Limestone County sting targeting online child exploitation
Madison County Record, News, The Madison Recor, ...
WES TOMLINSON The Decatur Daily 
November 18, 2026
LIMESTONE COUNTY - Fourteen men were arrested recently in an undercover operation targeting online child exploitation, the Limestone County Sheriff’s ...
TARCOG assists Town of Triana in developing up-todate comprehensive plan
Madison County Record, News, The Madison Recor, ...
Gregg Parker 
November 18, 2026
TRIANA – With growth comes change, and leaders in the Town of Triana are working to keep the town’s priorities on track by updating its Comprehensive ...
Forget-Me-Not seminar to train caregivers for dementia, Alzheimer’s disease patients
Events, Lifestyles, News, ...
Gregg Parker 
November 18, 2026
MADISON – Unfortunately, a diagnosis of dementia will affect practically everyone at some point – either in a personal evaluation or in the diagnosis ...
Movement Church to give food to cook Thanksgiving meal
Events, Lifestyles, Madison County Record, ...
Gregg Parker 
November 18, 2026
MADISON – With Thanksgiving Day approaching quickly, one Madison church is doing its part for residents to enjoy a tasty holiday meal. Movement Church...
Galaxy of Lights opens for 31st season, aims for #1 in USA Today competition
Events, Madison County Record, News, ...
Staff Reports 
November 18, 2026
HUNTSVILLE – Huntsville Botanical Garden (HBG) is once again in the national spotlight as Galaxy of Lights has been nominated for USA TODAY’s 10Best R...

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *