Columnists, Opinion
 By  Staff Reports news Published 
8:55 am Friday, June 4, 2010

Arizona and our national self-abatement

The Arizona immigration law has become the occasion for a sorry exercise in national self-abasement.
When Mexican President Felipe Calderon addressed a joint session of Congress recently, he rapped Arizonians — ignorantly and unfairly — for using “racial profiling as the basis for law enforcement.” If Democrats felt any residual reflex to stand up for their fellow Americans in Arizona, who are grappling with a hellish problem partly caused by the misgovernment of the country whose president stood before them, they swiftly repressed it.
They rose and applauded, and the president of Mexico and a majority of America’s Congress united in their disdain for Arizona’s handiwork. No one seemed to mind that they were cheering a man from a country where the kidnapping and abuse of migrants is “a human-rights crisis,” according to Amnesty International.
President Barack Obama tried to interpret the strange customs of his compatriots, who cling to guns, religion and a belief that the Southern border should mean something.
The law is a “misdirected expression of frustration over our broken immigration system,” Obama explained in his best sociological diagnosis. In other words, those poor boobs have deluded themselves up into thinking that checking the identification of suspected illegal immigrants makes sense.
In his reference to a “fair reading” of the law, Obama at least implied he had read the 10-page text, a feat beyond his cabinet. His attorney general and secretary of homeland security blasted away at the law without pausing even to give it a good skim.
And why would they? It wouldn’t change their view of the law, or its supporters. The country’s progressives believe that they are a lone oasis in a vast archipelago of racism and backwardness called the United States of America. If they apologize for their country, it’s only because they think they have so much for which to apologize.
Obama says that Justice Department lawyers are reviewing the law — or, more accurately, looking for any possible excuse to challenge it.
They’ll have to be creative.
A Department of Justice memo from 2002 says that states have the “inherent power” to make arrests for violations of federal law, and drafters of the Arizona statute were careful not to exceed federal statutes.
There are other, more direct ways to vitiate the law. Robert Morton, the head of Immigration and Customs Enforcement, says the government might “not necessarily process illegal immigrants referred to them by Arizona officials.” This is the nation’s top immigration cop flirting with civil disobedience against enforcement of the nation’s immigration laws. If Morton gets the vapors over asking suspected illegals for their ID, he’s clearly in the wrong line of work.
At bottom, the dispute over the state’s law is a conflict of visions. The law’s supporters believe we should take the border seriously, and assert the country’s sovereign right to control who comes here and who doesn’t; its detractors believe any serious effort to make good on that sovereign right is exclusionary and tinged with racism because it’s primarily directed at Latinos.
In this struggle, the latter camp sees Felipe Calderon as an ally, and thrills to his disparagement of their countrymen.

Rich Lowry is editor of the National Review.

(c) 2010 by King Features Synd., Inc.

Also on The Madison Record
A: Main, Madison County Record, News, ...
Staff Reports 
November 18, 2026
MADISON - Madison has been named the second best small city in America by Livability. com. In its inaugural list of the 50 Best Small Cities, the data...
A brother’s legacy builds joy for children battling cancer
A: Main, Lifestyles, Madison County Record, ...
Ten years after Josh Quist’s passing, his sister revives a LEGO toy drive to bring comfort and creativity to local children fighting cancer
Staff Reports 
November 18, 2026
HUNTSVILLE — For Josh Quist, a LEGO set offered something childhood cancer couldn’t take away: the freedom to imagine, create and simply be a kid. Ten...
Bartlett salutes Armed Forces whose service ‘spans decades and continents’
Madison County Record, News, The Madison Recor, ...
MADISON WEEKLY
Gregg Parker 
November 18, 2026
MADISON – In appreciation for all military personnel, Mayor Ranae Bartlett and Councilmembers Billie Goodson, Alice Lessmann and Erica White represent...
14 arrested in Limestone County sting targeting online child exploitation
Madison County Record, News, The Madison Recor, ...
WES TOMLINSON The Decatur Daily 
November 18, 2026
LIMESTONE COUNTY - Fourteen men were arrested recently in an undercover operation targeting online child exploitation, the Limestone County Sheriff’s ...
TARCOG assists Town of Triana in developing up-todate comprehensive plan
Madison County Record, News, The Madison Recor, ...
Gregg Parker 
November 18, 2026
TRIANA – With growth comes change, and leaders in the Town of Triana are working to keep the town’s priorities on track by updating its Comprehensive ...
Forget-Me-Not seminar to train caregivers for dementia, Alzheimer’s disease patients
Events, Lifestyles, News, ...
Gregg Parker 
November 18, 2026
MADISON – Unfortunately, a diagnosis of dementia will affect practically everyone at some point – either in a personal evaluation or in the diagnosis ...
Movement Church to give food to cook Thanksgiving meal
Events, Lifestyles, Madison County Record, ...
Gregg Parker 
November 18, 2026
MADISON – With Thanksgiving Day approaching quickly, one Madison church is doing its part for residents to enjoy a tasty holiday meal. Movement Church...

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *