Limestone Co. Sheriff’s Office: Violent felon arrested with weapon, stolen identities in multi-state fraud case
Madison County Record, News, The Madison Recor, Z - News Main
Staff Reports
 By Staff Reports  
Published 6:04 am Tuesday, July 8, 2025

Limestone Co. Sheriff’s Office: Violent felon arrested with weapon, stolen identities in multi-state fraud case

Keonta Demarius Cottingham

LIMESTONE COUNTY – According to the Limestone County Sheriff’s Office, a Birmingham man with a violent criminal history was arrested after detectives linked him to a multi-state identity theft and fraud case originating in Vermont.

Detectives with the Williston Police Department in Vermont contacted Captain Caleb Durden of the Limestone County Sheriff’s Office regarding a financial fraud investigation involving a local Vermont business.

The business had its banking information stolen, and fraudulent checks were deposited using a stolen identity. The suspect was tracked to Limestone County, Alabama.

Limestone deputies responded to a call at the suspect’s location and conducted a traffic stop on a vehicle leaving the scene. The driver, later identified as Keonta Demarius Cottingham, 27, of Birmingham, was found to be in possession of an AR-15 pistol in the passenger seat. Probable cause led investigators to search the vehicle, where they recovered multiple stolen identities, including the one used in the Vermont case.

Cottingham informed investigators of his violent criminal background, which includes previous charges of attempted murder, robbery, and shooting into occupied buildings. He is currently on probation from prior convictions.

Cottingham was arrested and charged with: Trafficking in Stolen Identities, Identity Theft and Possession of a Pistol by a Violent Felon.

The case remains under active investigation, and additional charges are anticipated, officials stated.

“The Limestone County Sheriff’s Office appreciates Sergeant Bart Chamberlain of the Williston Police Department’s collaboration in identifying and tracking this suspect. Thanks also to our deputies and investigators who acted quickly and thoroughly to stop this individual.”

“As our community continues to grow, we remind all residents that if you see something, say something,” said Sheriff Joshua McLaughlin. “Together, we can continue to protect our neighborhoods from dangerous individuals and criminal activity.”

Also on The Madison Record
Lady Patriots to play for State Championship
Madison County Record, News, Schools, ...
Bob Labbe 
March 5, 2026
The Bob Jones Lady Patriots are exactly where they expected prior to the start of the 2025-2026 season of high school basketball after they advanced t...
Mayor forms Small Business Advisory Council
A: Main, Business, Madison County Record, ...
MADISON WEEKLY
Gregg Parker 
March 4, 2026
MADISON – Last week, Madison Mayor Ranae Bartlett checked off a top priority on her inauguration to-do list: formation of the Mayor’s Small Business A...
Lady Patriots advance to Class 7A Final Four on Thursday
A: Main, Madison County Record, News, ...
Bob Jones will play in the Class 7A Semi-Finals on Thursday at 9 a.m.
Bob Labbe 
March 4, 2026
HARVEST - The Alabama High School Athletic Association’s annual Basketball State Tournament is set for this week with one local team making the Final ...
Library adds laser cutter with grant from Madison Visionary Partners
Lifestyles, Madison County Record, News, ...
Gregg Parker 
March 4, 2026
MADISON – A Community Impact Grant for $1,750 from Madison Visionary Partners or MVP has helped Madison Public Library in purchasing a laser cutter fo...
Tennessee Valley chapter named AAAA National Super Chapter of the Year
Madison County Record, News, The Madison Recor, ...
Special to THE RECORD news@themadisonrecord.com 
March 4, 2026
HUNTSVILLE - The Tennessee Valley Chapter of the Army Aviation Association of America has been named the AAAA National Super Chapter of the Year, a to...
25 MCS educators qualify as National Board Certified Teacher, 11 renew status
Madison County Record, News, Schools, ...
Gregg Parker 
March 4, 2026
MADISON – A new set of educators in Madison City Schools have attained NBCT status, considered the most respected professional certification available...
Principal Kristin Kolenich prepares for Russell Branch’s fall opening
Madison County Record, News, Schools, ...
Gregg Parker 
March 4, 2026
MADISON - Kristin Kolenich does not take the responsibility of her job lightly. Kolenich is Principal of Russell Branch Elementary School. “It is not ...

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *