Limestone Co. Sheriff’s Office: Violent felon arrested with weapon, stolen identities in multi-state fraud case
Madison County Record, News, The Madison Recor, Z - News Main
Staff Reports
 By Staff Reports  
Published 6:04 am Tuesday, July 8, 2025

Limestone Co. Sheriff’s Office: Violent felon arrested with weapon, stolen identities in multi-state fraud case

Keonta Demarius Cottingham

LIMESTONE COUNTY – According to the Limestone County Sheriff’s Office, a Birmingham man with a violent criminal history was arrested after detectives linked him to a multi-state identity theft and fraud case originating in Vermont.

Detectives with the Williston Police Department in Vermont contacted Captain Caleb Durden of the Limestone County Sheriff’s Office regarding a financial fraud investigation involving a local Vermont business.

The business had its banking information stolen, and fraudulent checks were deposited using a stolen identity. The suspect was tracked to Limestone County, Alabama.

Limestone deputies responded to a call at the suspect’s location and conducted a traffic stop on a vehicle leaving the scene. The driver, later identified as Keonta Demarius Cottingham, 27, of Birmingham, was found to be in possession of an AR-15 pistol in the passenger seat. Probable cause led investigators to search the vehicle, where they recovered multiple stolen identities, including the one used in the Vermont case.

Cottingham informed investigators of his violent criminal background, which includes previous charges of attempted murder, robbery, and shooting into occupied buildings. He is currently on probation from prior convictions.

Cottingham was arrested and charged with: Trafficking in Stolen Identities, Identity Theft and Possession of a Pistol by a Violent Felon.

The case remains under active investigation, and additional charges are anticipated, officials stated.

“The Limestone County Sheriff’s Office appreciates Sergeant Bart Chamberlain of the Williston Police Department’s collaboration in identifying and tracking this suspect. Thanks also to our deputies and investigators who acted quickly and thoroughly to stop this individual.”

“As our community continues to grow, we remind all residents that if you see something, say something,” said Sheriff Joshua McLaughlin. “Together, we can continue to protect our neighborhoods from dangerous individuals and criminal activity.”

Also on The Madison Record
City of Madison Update planned for Sept. 10 at VBC
A: Main, Events, Madison County Record, ...
Gregg Parker 
August 27, 2025
MADISON – Mayor Paul Finley will present “City of Madison Update” as a forum to announce current affairs and future projects for the community. The Ch...
MCS scores big in 2025 school rankings
A: Main, Madison County Record, News, ...
Staff Reports 
August 27, 2025
MADISON - Bob Jones and James Clemens high schools once again scored big in the annual U.S. News and World Report “Best High Schools in America” ranki...
City approves hotel market study for historic downtown
Business, Madison County Record, News, ...
Maria Rakoczy 
August 27, 2025
MADISON - The Madison City Council approved a hotel market feasibility study for the downtown area last week. Core Distribution Group, LLC will be con...
Kids to Love celebrates opening of Smith Family Wellness Center
Madison County Record, News, The Madison Recor, ...
Staff Reports 
August 27, 2025
MADISON - Amazing. That’s the word that best captures the night Kids to Love officially opened the doors of its most ambitious initiative yet—the Smit...
ShowerUp Huntsville brings showers and laundry services to those in need
Madison County Record, News, The Madison Recor, ...
By KADIE TAYLOR news@themadisonrecord.com 
August 27, 2025
MADISON - ShowerUp Huntsville provides free showers and laundry services to those in need in Madison, Huntsville and North Alabama. “We don’t require ...
Madison Witches Ride to return on Oct. 19, registration starts next week
Events, Madison County Record, News, ...
Gregg Parker 
August 27, 2025
MADISON – Sharpen those broom bristles. Dust off your pointed, black hat. Rehearse your spinetingling cackle. The time is near for the 2025 Madison Wi...
Library schedules films for ‘Mad Movie-A-Thon-O-Rama!’
Events, Madison County Record, News, ...
Gregg Parker 
August 27, 2025
MADISON – “Mad Movie- A-Thon-O-Rama!” returns to Madison Public Library with entertaining films – from campy to classic – for the remainder of 2025. T...
West Coast Swing Dance is on the menu every Tuesday at The Electric Belle
Madison County Record, News, The Madison Recor, ...
By KADIE TAYLOR news@themadisonrecord.com 
August 27, 2025
HUNTSVILLE - Everyone starts somewhere, if you have never danced, learn to swing at the Electric Belle. Located at the end of Gas Light Alley at Stove...

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *